---
title: 'Mel Tolkin'
canonical: 'https://interviews.televisionacademy.com/interviews/mel-tolkin'
published: '2025-02-18T20:49:42+00:00'
updated: '2026-06-16T19:09:21+00:00'
language: en
content-signal: search=yes
content-usage: search=y
license: 'https://interviews.televisionacademy.com/license.xml'
---

# Mel Tolkin

[30 Years of Interviews: The Stories That Started It All](/collections/30-years-of-interviews-the-stories-that-started-it-all)

Writer

[Play Full Interview](#)

About

"When you began in television, you didn't have a television set. It's an actual fact. And that's one of the biggest lessons in show business: too many people learned to write television from watching television, which is the reason so many of them are all alike. In fact, somebody once said that before you sit down to write, stand up and live. You have to learn from life, not from television."

About This Interview

In his four-hour interview, Mel Tolkin (1913-2007) talks about his early years writing for Camp Tamiment, where he was discovered by producer Max Liebman, and his writing partnership with Lucille Kallen. He discusses writing for such shows as *Admiral Broadway Revue*, *Your Show of Shows*, *Caesar's Hour* and *The Danny Kaye Show*. He describes writing for *All in the Family* as well, where he penned the controversial episode "Edith's 50th Birthday," and later for *Archie Bunker's Place.* He recalls shorter writing jobs on *The Danny Thomas Show*, *Joe's World*, and *Love, Sidney*. He also recalls working with Sid Caesar, Carl Reiner, and Howard Morris. Bob Claster conducted the interview on November 4, 1997 in Beverly Hills, CA.

**All views expressed by interviewees are theirs alone and not necessarily those of the Television Academy.**

People Talking About ...

[Mel Tolkin](/people/mel-tolkin)

Highlights ![Thumbnail of Mel Tolkin](https://img.youtube.com/vi/R5LWYoH7GHA/mqdefault.jpg)

Mel Tolkin on his first impressions of Sid Caesar and on their relationship

03:26

 ![Thumbnail of Mel Tolkin](https://img.youtube.com/vi/90vVg3Bj_eg/mqdefault.jpg)

Mel Tolkin on his mother visiting him on *Your Show of Shows*

02:06

 ![Thumbnail of Mel Tolkin](https://img.youtube.com/vi/R5LWYoH7GHA/mqdefault.jpg)

Mel Tolkin on how *Your Show of Shows* was different from *Admiral Broadway Revue*, and on discovering Sid Caesar's talents

04:23

 ![Thumbnail of Mel Tolkin](https://img.youtube.com/vi/NDxrNS14iBE/mqdefault.jpg)

Mel Tolkin on the end of *Your Show of Shows*

04:14

 ![Thumbnail of Mel Tolkin](https://img.youtube.com/vi/0FqqDDz4IPY/mqdefault.jpg)

Mel Tolkin on the challenges of writing for the "Archie Bunker" character on *All in the Family*, and on story ideas he had for the show

02:56

 ![Thumbnail of Mel Tolkin](https://img.youtube.com/vi/0S8V9FFUFxk/mqdefault.jpg)

Mel Tolkin on writing the controversial *All in the Family* episode "Edith's 50th Birthday"

02:32

Full Interview [Play Full Interview](#)

## Chapter 1

On his early life and influences; on his hobbies as a kid; on radio he listened to growing up and movies he enjoyed

15:11

On realizing he wanted to be a writer; on his accent, and on his earliest experiences with television

06:25

On life in New York City in 1945, and on Camp Tamiment; on meeting Max Liebman and Lucille Kallen

06:42

## Chapter 2

On *Admiral Broadway Revue* and later *Your Show of Shows* producer Max Liebman; on what Liebman saw in Tolkin's talents when he worked at the Poconos resort Camp Tamiment; on his first impressions of Sid Caesar, whom he met on *Admiral Broadway Revue*, and on their relationship

09:43

On the talents of Imogene Coca on *Admiral Broadway Revue* and later on *Your Show of Shows*; on the format of *Admiral Broadway Revue*, and the use of previously written material from when he and co-writer Lucille Kallen worked at Camp Tamiment; on writing for Sid Caesar and Imogene Coca on *Admiral Broadway Revue*

08:00

On the creation of *Your Show of Shows*; on how *Your Show of Shows* was different from *Admiral Broadway Revue* and on discovering Sid Caesar's talents; on writers Carl Reiner and Howard Morris

08:55

## Chapter 3

On his mother visiting him on *Your Show of Shows*; on his writing partner Lucille Kallen working on *Your Show of Shows*; on working with Mel Brooks on *Your Show of Shows*

08:57

On working with Tony Webster and Joe Stein on *Your Show of Shows*; on Danny and Neil Simon writing for *Your Show of Shows*; on the most memorable sketches on *Your Show of Shows* and the types of sketches they did

13:51

On how much of *Your Show of Shows* was improvised on-camera, and on the "This is Your Story" sketch; on the pantomime segments of *Your Shows of Shows*

06:05

## Chapter 4

On *Your Show of Shows* being sued over their satire of "From Here to Eternity"; on the pressure of working on *Your Show of Shows*; on the end of *Your Show of Shows*

10:26

On the Hollywood Blacklist; on splitting up with Lucille Kallen when she went to write for *The Imogene Coca Show* and he went to write for *Caesar's Hour*; on the writing staff of *Caesar's Hour*, and on being the show's head writer

09:34

On Mel Brooks writing for *Caesar's Hour*; on the *Caesar's Hour* writers Sheldon Keller, Selma Diamond, Gary Belkin, and Mike Stewart; on *Caesar's Hour* writers Larry Gelbart and Woody Allen

08:33

## Chapter 5

On the talent of the writing staff of *Caesar's Hour*, and on comparing it to *Your Show of Shows*; on writing for Nanette Fabray on *Caesar's Hour*, and comparing her to Imogene Coca; on classic sketches from *Caesar's Hour*, and on the end of the show

15:22

On how television changed and evolved from the 1950s to the 1980s; on writing for *The Danny Thomas Show*, and on working with producer Sheldon Leonard; on how writing sketches differed from writing a sitcom like *The Danny Thomas Show*

13:46

## Chapter 6

On writing specific episodes of *The Danny Thomas Show*; on writing for *I'm Dickens ... He's Fenster* and for *The Danny Kaye Show* with Larry Gelbart; on writing *The Sid Caesar, Imogene Coca, Carl Reiner, Howard Morris Special* and on his deal with Universal Television

11:48

On writing *The Good Guys*, starring Bob Denver and Alan Hale, Jr.; on writing for Bob Hope

08:15

On writing for *All in the Family* with writing partner Larry Rhine and on working with Norman Lear; on the challenges of writing for the "Archie Bunker" character on *All in the Family*, and on story ideas he had for the show; on Norman Lear's day-to-day involvement with *All in the Family*, and on the shooting schedule of the show

08:54

## Chapter 7

On writing the controversial *All in the Family* episode "Edith's 50th Birthday"; on how *All in the Family* changed over the years, and on dealing with cast members leaving; on writing for *Archie Bunker's Place*, starring Carroll O'Connor

07:19

On writing *Joe's World* with Norman Lear; on writing for *Love, Sidney*, starring Tony Randall in which the lead character was homosexual; on teaching comedy writing at UCLA and on the then-current state of television comedy

07:05

On his desire to continue working, and on then-current projects; on his accomplishments and his regrets; on the benefits of writing with a partner, and on the best of television

06:22

On attending a reunion of the writers of *Your Show of Shows*; on how he'd like to be remembered; on various people he's worked with in his career

07:38

## Chapter 8

On various people with whom he's worked in his career; on his sons and wife

08:44

On b-roll pictures from his career- with a nightclub band; with a marching band; Tamiment Playhouse program; with Lucille Kallen; headshot of Sid Caesar; with Sid Caesar on the set of *Your Show of Shows*; the entire creative team of *Your Show of Shows*; the writing team of *Caesar's Hour*; reunion of Sid Caesar's writers; with Neil Simon, Nathan Lane, Sid Caesar, and Carl Reiner; on the set of *The Danny Kaye Show*; with Jerry Lewis; Bob Hope writers; posing with his awards; bit of wisdom

09:05

Shows

## [Admiral Broadway Revue](/shows/admiral-broadway-revue)

Mel Tolkin on *Admiral Broadway Revue* and later *Your Show of Shows* producer Max Liebman

02:51

Mel Tolkin on what *Admiral Broadway Revue* producer Max Liebman saw in Tolkin's talents when he worked at the Poconos resort Camp Tamiment

01:00

Mel Tolkin on getting into television with the short-lived *Admiral Broadway Revue*

02:26

Mel Tolkin on the talents of Imogene Coca on *Admiral Broadway Revue* and later on *Your Show of Shows*

02:38

Mel Tolkin on the format of *Admiral Broadway Revue* and the use of previously written material from when he and co-writer Lucille Kallen worked at the Poconos resort Camp Tamiment

02:38

Mel Tolkin on writing for Sid Caesar and Imogene Coca on *Admiral Broadway Revue*

02:44

Mel Tolkin on how *Your Show of Shows* was different from *Admiral Broadway Revue*, and on discovering Sid Caesar's talents

04:23

## [All in the Family](/shows/all-in-the-family)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *All in the Family* with writing partner Larry Rhine, and on working with Norman Lear

04:02

Mel Tolkin on the challenges of writing for the "Archie Bunker" character on *All in the Family*, and on story ideas he had for the show

02:56

Mel Tolkin on Norman Lear's day-to-day involvement with *All in the Family*, and on the shooting schedule of the show

01:56

Mel Tolkin on writing the controversial *All in the Family* episode "Edith's 50th Birthday"

02:32

Mel Tolkin on how *All in the Family* changed over the years, and on dealing with cast members leaving

02:27

## [Archie Bunker's Place](/shows/archie-bunkers-place)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Archie Bunker's Place*, starring Carroll O'Connor

02:20

## [Bob Hope Specials](/shows/bob-hope-specials)

Mel Tolkin on writing for Bob Hope

07:07

## [Caesar's Hour](/shows/caesars-hour)

Mel Tolkin on splitting up with Lucille Kallen when she went to write for *The Imogene Coca Show* and he went to write for *Caesar's Hour*

02:06

Mel Tolkin on the writing staff of *Caesar's Hour*, and on being the show's head writer

05:18

Mel Tolkin on Mel Brooks writing for *Caesar's Hour*

02:02

Mel Tolkin on the *Caesar's Hour* writers Sheldon Keller, Selma Diamond, Gary Belkin, and Mike Stewart

04:32

Mel Tolkin on *Caesar's Hour* writers Larry Gelbart and Woody Allen

01:55

Mel Tolkin on the talent of the writing staff of *Caesar's Hour*, and on comparing it to *Your Show of Shows*

02:21

Mel Tolkin on writing for Nanette Fabray on *Caesar's Hour*, and comparing her to Imogene Coca

01:54

Mel Tolkin on classic sketches from *Caesar's Hour* featuring Sid Caesar

07:54

Mel Tolkin on the end of *Caesar's Hour*

03:12

## [Danny Thomas Hour, The](/shows/danny-thomas-hour-the)

Mel Tolkin on how writing sketches differed from writing a sitcom like *The Danny Thomas Show*

04:44

## [Danny Thomas Show, The aka Make Room for Daddy](/shows/danny-thomas-show-the-aka-make-room-for-daddy)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *The Danny Thomas Show*, and on working with producer Sheldon Leonard

02:58

Mel Tolkin on writing specific episodes of *The Danny Thomas Show*

02:19

## [Good Guys, The](/shows/good-guys-the)

Mel Tolkin on writing *The Good Guys*, starring Bob Denver and Alan Hale, Jr.

01:08

## [I'm Dickens ... He's Fenster](/shows/im-dickens-hes-fenster)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *I'm Dickens ... He's Fenster* and for *The Danny Kaye Show* with Larry Gelbart

04:02

## [Love, Sidney](/shows/love-sidney)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Love, Sidney*, starring Tony Randall in which the lead character was homosexual

02:59

## [Sid Caesar, Imogene Coca, Carl Reiner, Howard Morris Special, The](/shows/sid-caesar-imogene-coca-carl-reiner-howard-morris-special-the)

Mel Tolkin on writing *The Sid Caesar, Imogene Coca, Carl Reiner, Howard Morris Special*, and on his deal with Universal Television

05:27

## [Your Show of Shows](/shows/your-show-of-shows)

Mel Tolkin on *Admiral Broadway Revue* and later *Your Show of Shows* producer Max Liebman

02:51

Mel Tolkin on his first impressions of Sid Caesar, who he met on *Admiral Broadway Revue*, and on their relationship

03:26

Mel Tolkin on the talents of Imogene Coca on *Admiral Broadway Revue* and later on *Your Show of Shows*

02:38

Mel Tolkin on the talents of performer/writer Carl Reiner on *Your Show of Shows*

01:30

Mel Tolkin on the talents and temperament of performer Howard Morris on *Your Show of Shows*

00:35

Mel Tolkin on the creation of *Your Show of Shows*

02:26

Mel Tolkin on his mother visiting him on *Your Show of Shows*

02:06

Mel Tolkin on his writing partner Lucille Kallen working on *Your Show of Shows*

02:55

Mel Tolkin on working with Mel Brooks on *Your Show of Shows*

03:55

Mel Tolkin on working with Tony Webster and Joe Stein on *Your Show of Shows*

02:33

Mel Tolkin on Danny and Neil Simon writing for *Your Show of Shows*

01:51

Mel Tolkin on the most memorable sketches on *Your Show of Shows* and the types of sketches they did

09:27

Mel Tolkin on how much of *Your Show of Shows* was improvised on-camera, and on the "This is Your Story" sketch

03:07

Mel Tolkin on the pantomime segments of *Your Shows of Shows*, and on where he was when the show was airing

02:58

Mel Tolkin on *Your Show of Shows* being sued over their satire of "From Here to Eternity"

01:11

Mel Tolkin on the pressure of working on *Your Show of Shows*

05:01

Mel Tolkin on the end of *Your Show of Shows*

04:14

Mel Tolkin on the talent of the writing staff of *Caesar's Hour*, and on comparing it to *Your Show of Shows*

02:21

Mel Tolkin on attending a reunion of the writers of *Your Show of Shows*

01:06

Topics

## [Characters &amp; Catchphrases](/topics/characters-catchphrases)

Mel Tolkin on the challenges of writing for the "Archie Bunker" character on *All in the Family*, and on story ideas he had for the show

02:56

## [Comedy-Variety](/topics/comedy-variety)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Your Show of Shows*

08:55

Mel Tolkin on classic sketches from *Caesar's Hour* featuring Sid Caesar

07:54

## [Hollywood Blacklist](/topics/hollywood-blacklist)

Mel Tolkin on the Hollywood Blacklist

02:10

## [Industry Crossroads](/topics/industry-crossroads)

Mel Tolkin on the Hollywood Blacklist

02:10

## [Pop Culture](/topics/pop-culture)

Mel Tolkin on the challenges of writing for the "Archie Bunker" character on *All in the Family*, and on story ideas he had for the show

02:56

## [Television Industry](/topics/television-industry)

Mel Tolkin on the Hollywood Blacklist

02:10

Mel Tolkin on how television changed and evolved from the 1950s to the 1980s

06:04

Mel Tolkin on the benefits of writing with a partner, and on the best of television

02:42

## [TV's Golden Age (1940s &amp; '50s)](/topics/tvs-golden-age-1940s-50s)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Your Show of Shows*

08:55

Mel Tolkin on classic sketches from *Caesar's Hour* featuring Sid Caesar

07:54

Professions

## [Writers](/professions/writers)

Mel Tolkin on how writing sketches differed from writing a sitcom like *The Danny Thomas Show*

04:44

Mel Tolkin on teaching comedy writing at UCLA, and on the then-current state of television comedy

02:58

Mel Tolkin on the benefits of writing with a partner, and on the best of television

02:43

Genres

## [Comedy Series](/genres/comedy-series)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *The Danny Thomas Show*

02:19

Mel Tolkin on writing for *I'm Dickens ... He's Fenster* and for *The Danny Kaye Show* with Larry Gelbart

04:02

Mel Tolkin on writing *The Good Guys*, starring Bob Denver and Alan Hale, Jr.

01:08

Mel Tolkin on writing for *All in the Family*

08:54

Mel Tolkin on writing for *All in the Family* and *Archie Bunker's Place*

07:19

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Joe's World*

01:08

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Love, Sidney*

02:59

## [Music Shows &amp; Variety Shows/Specials](/genres/music-shows-variety-showsspecials)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Admiral Broadway Revue*

17:43

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Your Show of Shows*

08:55

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Your Show of Shows*

28:53

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Your Show of Shows*

10:26

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Caesar's Hour*

15:57

Mel Tolkin on writing for *Caesar's Hour*

15:22

Mel Tolkin on writing for *The Danny Thomas Show*

07:42

Mel Tolkin on writing for *I'm Dickens ... He's Fenster* and for *The Danny Kaye Show* with Larry Gelbart

04:02

Mel Tolkin on writing *The Sid Caesar, Imogene Coca, Carl Reiner, Howard Morris Special*, and on his deal with Universal Television

05:27

People

## [Woody Allen](/people/woody-allen)

Mel Tolkin on *Caesar's Hour* writers Larry Gelbart and Woody Allen

01:55

## [Mel Brooks](/people/mel-brooks)

Mel Tolkin on working with Mel Brooks on *Your Show of Shows*

03:55

Mel Tolkin on Mel Brooks writing for *Caesar's Hour*

02:02

## [Dave Caesar](/people/dave-caesar)

Mel Tolkin on Dave Caesar

01:03

## [Sid Caesar](/interviews/sid-caesar)

Mel Tolkin on his first impressions of Sid Caesar and on their relationship

01:49

Mel Tolkin on writing for Sid Caesar and Imogene Coca on *Admiral Broadway Revue*

02:44

Mel Tolkin on how *Your Show of Shows* was different from *Admiral Broadway Revue*, and on discovering Sid Caesar's talents

04:23

Mel Tolkin on classic sketches from *Caesar's Hour* featuring Sid Caesar

07:54

## [Imogene Coca](/people/imogene-coca)

Mel Tolkin on writing for Sid Caesar and Imogene Coca on *Admiral Broadway Revue*

02:44

Mel Tolkin on splitting up with Lucille Kallen when she went to write for *The Imogene Coca Show* and he went to write for *Caesar's Hour*

02:06

Mel Tolkin on writing for Nanette Fabray on *Caesar's Hour*, and comparing her to Imogene Coca

01:54

## [Bob Denver](/people/bob-denver)

Mel Tolkin on writing *The Good Guys*, starring Bob Denver and Alan Hale, Jr.

01:08

## [Selma Diamond](/people/selma-diamond)

Mel Tolkin on the *Caesar's Hour* writers Sheldon Keller, Selma Diamond, Gary Belkin, and Mike Stewart

04:32

## [Jimmy Durante](/people/jimmy-durante)

Mel Tolkin on Jimmy Durante

00:46

## [Nanette Fabray](/interviews/nanette-fabray)

Mel Tolkin on writing for Nanette Fabray on *Caesar's Hour*, and comparing her to Imogene Coca

01:54

## [Larry Gelbart](/interviews/larry-gelbart)

Mel Tolkin on *Caesar's Hour* writers Larry Gelbart and Woody Allen

01:55

Mel Tolkin on writing for *I'm Dickens ... He's Fenster* and for *The Danny Kaye Show* with Larry Gelbart

04:02

## [Bob Hope](/people/bob-hope)

Mel Tolkin on writing for Bob Hope

07:07

Mel Tolkin on Bob Hope

00:26

## [Milt Josefsberg](/people/milt-josefsberg)

Mel Tolkin on Milt Josefsberg

00:29

## [Alan Hale, Jr.](/people/alan-hale-jr)

Mel Tolkin on writing *The Good Guys*, starring Bob Denver and Alan Hale, Jr.

01:08

## [Lucille Kallen](/interviews/lucille-kallen)

Mel Tolkin on meeting Max Liebman and Lucille Kallen

02:45

Mel Tolkin on his writing partner Lucille Kallen working on *Your Show of Shows*

02:55

Mel Tolkin on splitting up with Lucille Kallen when she went to write for *The Imogene Coca Show* and he went to write for *Caesar's Hour*

02:06

## [Danny Kaye](/people/danny-kaye)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *I'm Dickens ... He's Fenster* and for *The Danny Kaye Show* with Larry Gelbart

04:02

Mel Tolkin on Danny Kaye

01:16

## [Norman Lear](/interviews/norman-lear)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *All in the Family* with writing partner Larry Rhine, and on working with Norman Lear

04:02

Mel Tolkin on Norman Lear's day-to-day involvement with *All in the Family*, and on the shooting schedule of the show

01:56

Mel Tolkin on writing *Joe's World* with Norman Lear

01:08

## [Sheldon Leonard](/interviews/sheldon-leonard)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *The Danny Thomas Show*, and on working with producer Sheldon Leonard

02:58

## [Max Liebman](/people/max-liebman)

Mel Tolkin on meeting Max Liebman and Lucille Kallen

02:45

Mel Tolkin on *Your Show of Shows* and *Admiral Broadway Revue* producer Max Liebman

02:55

## [Howard Morris](/interviews/howard-morris)

Mel Tolkin on the talents and temperament of performer Howard Morris on *Your Show of Shows*

00:33

## [Carroll O'Connor](/interviews/carroll-oconnor)

Mel Tolkin on Carroll O'Connor

00:50

## [Tony Randall](/interviews/tony-randall)

Mel Tolkin on Tony Randall

00:55

## [Carl Reiner](/interviews/carl-reiner)

Mel Tolikn on the talents of performer/writer Carl Reiner on *Your Show of Shows*

01:30

## [Rob Reiner](/interviews/rob-reiner)

Mel Tolkin on Jean Stapleton, Rob Reiner, and Sally Struthers

02:32

## [Larry Rhine](/interviews/larry-rhine)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *All in the Family* with writing partner Larry Rhine, and on working with Norman Lear

04:02

## [Neil Simon](/people/neil-simon)

Mel Tolkin on Danny and Neil Simon writing for *Your Show of Shows*

01:51

## [Jean Stapleton](/interviews/jean-stapleton)

Mel Tolkin on Jean Stapleton, Rob Reiner, and Sally Struthers

02:32

## [Sally Struthers](/people/sally-struthers)

Mel Tolkin on Jean Stapleton, Rob Reiner, and Sally Struthers

02:32

## [Danny Thomas](/people/danny-thomas)

Mel Tolkin on writing for *The Danny Thomas Show*, and on working with producer Sheldon Leonard

02:58

Mel Tolkin on writing specific episodes of *The Danny Thomas Show*

02:19

## [Sylvester L. "Pat" Weaver](/people/sylvester-l-pat-weaver)

Mel Tolkin on Sylvester L. Weaver

00:26